Rule details on Opinionated Days (judge) & Rebelling/shooting

[Lumino]

So I've looked everywhere and I haven't found the answer but here's the situation.

 

V.V Doom was holding an opinionated 50-50 rail grind day. Of course some people lived and some died. However at one point, Doom didn't shoot a player but mewa decided to shoot the person instead. I asked why the person was shot. Mewa stated that "it was horrible". This whole entire time I was under the impression that only the person hosting the opinionated day was allowed to decide whether or not the contestant died.

 

1)Is the warden/host the only person who can decide whether or not a player dies?

2)Can the warden choose other Ct's to judge or come up with a decision?

 

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

On another note:

 

On MOTD under T's where "Thing that can get you killed" this is listed..

 

•holding a gun for longer than 3 seconds, or shooting at a CT

 

 

1)What's the point of the holding the gun for 3 seconds rule if they turn red in 5. Then I get complaints that people weren't FK'd because "they had a gun out". With this rule active I can't tell a CT I didn't see him count 3 seconds. At this point Ts during a freeday can keep complaining in chat about how they got free killed and then the CT in question can just say they held a gun for 3 seconds and they know damn well they didn't count or for all you know the T didn't even HAVE a weapon. Admins can't always spec EVERY single person during freedays especially when they're playing. The rule should just be changed to the 5 second rule so by then the T would be RED and their name wouldn't appear in console as freekilling.

 

2)Now the shooting at a CT rule is sort of eh for me. (lack of better words)

 

Let's say a T was in LR mode and was just havin fun with a gun shootin around CTs. Some CT could take that as a threat and then kill the poor fellow. Now there aren't many more ways (not saying there aren't more) that this situation could fit in but it'd just make sense to go with the "in order to be killable you must be red" category.

 

Now I'm not just trying to nitpick rules really but make things more certain and solid. It's just that the console really helps on judgements of freekilling and wutnot and certainly weeds out the people DO know and DON'T know what they're doing. This usually refers to the new people who join CT. It takes a big toll mostly on the CSGO jb server because EVERYDAY you have a few newbies coming in and joining CT and then complaints are yelled through *dead* chat.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

So I would just like your opinions and clarifications on the top 2 sections.

For future reference all those that reply thank you for your time.

[MasterBaiter]

If lead give a specific right to judge on your day then they may do that. Unless they are instructed by the lead to kill them then it ways a freekill. I have done it where i have people judge and even t's judge there own.

[Bonbon]

•holding a gun for longer than 3 seconds, or shooting at a CT

 

 

1)What's the point of the holding the gun for 3 seconds rule if they turn red in 5.

 

The point of the "holding the gun for 3 second" rule is because you turn red in 3 seconds. Not 5. 3. That is so Ts know that if they hold out a gun for three seconds, they're going to turn red and can be shot. So, the CT doesn't have to do ANY counting. If they THINK that it's been three seconds, and that person isn't red, than that person needs to go back to counting class.

 

The rule should just be changed to the 5 second rule so by then the T would be RED and their name wouldn't appear in console as freekilling.

 

What? Read above. You turn red after 3 seconds, NOT 5. You turn red FOR 5 seconds AFTER you've held a gun out for 3 seconds.

[EtherealHope]

1)Is the warden/host the only person who can decide whether or not a player dies?

2)Can the warden choose other Ct's to judge or come up with a decision?

 

The only way another CT can kill a T during an Opinionated Day is if he DESIGNATES another CT to do so. Otherwise, it is a freekill if that T is not killing by the lead.

 

1)What's the point of the holding the gun for 3 seconds rule if they turn red in 5.

 

Bonbon has already explained this. Lol. The T turns red for 5 seconds after holding a gun out for 3 seconds, just to clear that up.

 

2)Now the shooting at a CT rule is sort of eh for me. (lack of better words)

 

Let's say a T was in LR mode and was just havin fun with a gun shootin around CTs. Some CT could take that as a threat and then kill the poor fellow. Now there aren't many more ways (not saying there aren't more) that this situation could fit in but it'd just make sense to go with the "in order to be killable you must be red" category.

 

IMO, when it comes to shooting at CTs as a T, to be rebelling you have to actually HIT THEM. Lol. Red = Dead obviously so if the T doesn't become red, then they aren't rebelling unless not following directions of course. Now, with the LR thing, that would be freekilling. LR is a reward a T gets for surviving the day and completing all tasks set by the lead. The only time a T should be shot on LR is if he's red, if it's S4S or if he lost the game. "in order to be killable you must be red" doesn't necessarily work because if you are in Soccer on a day they are doing 300, that's rebelling by not following orders but in almost every other case, that statement is true.

 

Hope this explained things a little bit more for you. Also wait for a dL or uM to come by and approve of this before implementing it into the server, even though I'm pretty sure all of this information is true.

[RedDevil6193]

1)Is the warden/host the only person who can decide whether or not a player dies?

2)Can the warden choose other Ct's to judge or come up with a decision?

 

Yes if lead says you guys decide and lead says you can kill him then they can otherwise without lead's perm they cant kill unless the t rebels.

 

 

2)Now the shooting at a CT rule is sort of eh for me. (lack of better words)

 

Let's say a T was in LR mode and was just havin fun with a gun shootin around CTs. Some CT could take that as a threat and then kill the poor fellow. Now there aren't many more ways (not saying there aren't more) that this situation could fit in but it'd just make sense to go with the "in order to be killable you must be red" category.

 

Now I'm not just trying to nitpick rules really but make things more certain and solid. It's just that the console really helps on judgements of freekilling and wutnot and certainly weeds out the people DO know and DON'T know what they're doing. This usually refers to the new people who join CT. It takes a big toll mostly on the CSGO jb server because EVERYDAY you have a few newbies coming in and joining CT and then complaints are yelled through *dead* chat.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

So I would just like your opinions and clarifications on the top 2 sections.

For future reference all those that reply thank you for your time.

 

If its a freeday or lr, then dont shoot or kill them for shooting unless red lol.